Saturday, May 6, 2023

Vienna Lager: The Amber Style That Nearly Vanished From Vienna

Vienna lager is a copper-coloured, bottom-fermented beer whose malt tastes of toast and bread crust rather than of caramel, bittered gently and fermented dry enough that the colour promises more sweetness than the finish gives. The style came out of one nineteenth-century brewer getting control of two things at once, the malt and the cold, and it then did something unusual: it spread across the world and largely disappeared from the city that named it. You will meet the name on a bottle list, in a malt catalogue and on a BC tap, so it is worth knowing what each of those uses actually refers to.

A stemmed glass of amber lager on a stone railing at sunset, with a city skyline of church spires behind

How To Judge A Vienna Lager

  • Order a beer built on toasted malt and not on crystal malt, because the two taste different and only one of them is what the style name is supposed to mean.
  • Serve the beer cold but not numbing, and pour it in one go so the head forms and then settles.
  • Buy a Märzen as well and pour the two side by side, since the difference between them is the difference between bread crust and weight.
  • Give the bottle time in a cold cellar, because a young amber lager still carries a green, yeasty edge.

What Dreher Changed

Anton Dreher brewed at Schwechat, just outside Vienna, and the beer he is credited with from the early 1840s solved two separate problems at the same time. Cold bottom fermentation, the Bavarian practice of lagering beer in icy cellars, already produced a clean and stable beer, but colour and flavour were the awkward part, because the malt of the day ran from pale to dark and rarely gave a toasty note without an edge of roast or a cloying sweetness underneath it. Dreher's contribution was a way of drying and kilning malt that produced even, amber, lightly toasted grain, and marrying that malt to the new lagering practice gave a beer that looked rich and drank dry.

The same decade produced the pale Bohemian lager out of Plzeň, which is why the two are still confused by people meeting them for the first time, and why Vienna malt sits in a malt catalogue long after the beer that named it became a niche. The style itself travelled fast through Central Europe and then further, carried by railway, by emigrant brewers and by the general fashion for anything Austrian in the late nineteenth century.

Vienna Malt Is Not The Same As The Beer

Most homebrewers meet the name first as an ingredient. Vienna malt is kilned hotter than pale malt and cooler than Munich malt, which puts it in the band where grain turns golden to light amber and begins to smell of bread crust rather than of toast and coffee. It can carry a large share of a grist, and brewers reach for it because it gives them colour and a dry, biscuity flavour in the same handful, without the sweetness a dark crystal malt adds to reach a similar shade.

That distinction is worth holding onto when you read about the beer, because an amber lager built from a pale base and a heavy share of Vienna malt is following Dreher's logic, while an amber lager built from pale malt and crystal malt is a different beer wearing the same colour. The first finishes clean and tastes of the crust of a loaf, the second finishes soft and tastes of toffee, and only one of them is what the style name is supposed to mean.

How The Style Reads In The Glass

  • The colour runs from deep gold through copper to light reddish amber, and it should be brilliant rather than hazy, since a lager this clean shows its clarity as part of the presentation.
  • The aroma is grainy and toasty with no roast, no coffee and no fruit in it, and a faint floral or herbal note from noble hops sitting behind the malt rather than in front of it.
  • The first third of the flavour is malt, round and lightly sweet, and the beer then attenuates out from under that sweetness into a dry finish instead of landing sticky.
  • Bitterness is present but modest, enough to stop the malt reading as cloying, and it is never the point of the beer.
  • Strength usually sits in the mid fives by volume, which is part of what makes the style drinkable across a long meal.
  • Mouthfeel is medium rather than creamy, and the carbonation is firm, because the beer relies on that prickle to keep the amber malt from feeling heavy.

Brewing One Yourself

StageWhat to doWhy it matters
GrainA pale two-row base with a large share of Vienna malt and some Munich behind itThe malt has to supply the colour and the toast together, so no dark grain is needed
MashingA single infusion in the mid sixties, or a short decoction if you want the traditional routeEnough body to carry the toast without leaving real residual sweetness
HopsNoble hops, a modest bittering charge and a late addition for aromaBitterness should hold the malt in check rather than compete with it
BoilA full rolling boil with the lid off the kettleDriving off the cooked-corn note that pale and amber malts both bring to a gentle boil
FermentationA clean lager strain running cool, then a couple of warm days before it goes coldThe warm finish lets the yeast remove the buttery compounds it makes along the way
ConditioningSeveral weeks close to freezing, and keep it cold afterwardsThe soft roundness that defines the style is mostly time and cold
WaterModerately hard rather than stripped, with enough calcium for the mashVery soft water flattens amber malt and leaves the beer tasting hollow

None of that is difficult, and the style is a good second lager to attempt after a Helles, because the malt does more of the talking and the margin for error on bitterness is wider. Where people fail with it is in the rush, since a three-week version of this beer tastes thin, sweet and green all at once, and the fix is a calendar rather than a recipe change.

Serving It With Food

Vienna lager is one of the easiest beers to eat with, because toasted malt follows the same browning chemistry as roasted food. Anything with a crust sits well beside it, so roast chicken, sausages grilled hard on the outside, a slow-cooked shoulder, pork schnitzel and a wedge of onion tart all find something to agree with in the glass, and firm aged cheese works for the same reason. The carbonation and the modest bitterness cut through fat in a way that a heavier, sweeter amber ale would not manage.

Serve it cold but not numbing, in a clean lager glass, and pour it in one go so the head forms and then settles. Two things ruin this style at home: serving it warm enough that the malt turns sweet and flat, and keeping bottles long past the point where the hop aroma has faded, since an aged example loses precisely the note that makes the beer worth opening.

Where The Style Went

Inside Austria, the amber lager that carried the city's name became a smaller part of what breweries produced as taste moved paler and as the number of brewing houses fell through the twentieth century. The style did better outside its homeland than inside it. Central European brewers emigrated in the nineteenth century and set up breweries as far away as Mexico, where the amber lager tradition took root and lasted, and the growth of small breweries in North America brought the style back into style guides in the closing decades of the twentieth century, when working backwards through older beer lists was one way of making something unlike pale lager.

A style can outlive the breweries that invented it and still be called by the city where it started, which is why the name on a bottle tells you about a recipe rather than about a place.

That gap between name and place is also why you should treat any article that names a current Viennese brewery, its founding year and the amber beer it pours with some caution. Brewery listings go stale quickly, some of the names that circulate in beer writing are hard to trace at all, and a founding date copied from one page to the next stops being evidence, so check a brewery's present status against a current listing before you plan a visit around it or build a shopping list from a decade-old guide.

Vienna, Märzen And Dunkel Side By Side

BeerColourWhat the malt saysFinish
Vienna lagerCopper to light amberBread crust and light toastDry, with the bitterness visible
MärzenAmber to deep goldRicher, and more of the same crusty maltSoft and dry rather than sweet
Munich dunkelBrownToasted crust with a hint of chocolateRound and smooth
Crystal malt amber aleAmberToffee and caramelFull and sweet-edged

Reading the table down the middle is the fastest way to work out what you actually enjoyed at the last beer festival, since most people who say they like an amber lager mean they like bread crust, and most who say the same about a dark malt beer mean chocolate. The two come from different parts of the kiln and they ask for different food.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Vienna lager the same thing as a Märzen?

No, though they are neighbours and plenty of people pour them in the wrong order. Märzen uses a larger share of the same kind of malt and gets a deeper colour and a richer, fuller flavour out of it, while a Vienna lager is lighter in the mouth, drier, and more about the crusty toasted note than about weight. If an amber beer tastes of toffee it is probably neither of the two, and if it tastes of coffee it is a long way from both.

Why did my Vienna malt lager come out so pale?

Malt gives colour in proportion to how hot it was kilned and how much of it went into the grist, so a beer built on a pale base with a small amount of Vienna malt will land gold rather than copper. Raising the Vienna share and putting some Munich malt behind it moves the colour and the toast together, and a longer boil darkens the wort a little further through caramelization. What you want to avoid is fixing the colour with roasted grain, which brings coffee and ash into a beer meant to taste of bread.

Does an amber lager need a long conditioning period?

It needs longer than most people plan for, because the green, yeasty edge of a young lager is exactly what stands between this beer and the soft toasty roundness it is supposed to have. Five weeks cold will usually take the roughness out, and eight will make the malt taste sweeter than it did without adding any sugar, which is the odd thing about lagering: it works by removing harshness rather than by adding flavour.

Is a red lager the same as a Vienna lager?

The word red has been attached to so many beers in North America that it has stopped describing much, and you will find copper lagers, amber lagers and genuinely reddish beers all sold under it. The useful question is where the colour came from: a beer that gets its shade from moderately kilned amber malt tastes toasty and finishes dry, while one that reaches the same hue with crystal malt or a whisper of roasted barley tastes sweeter or drier in ways that change what you should eat with it.

What To Look For On A BC Shelf

British Columbia stocks enough amber and copper lager to make this a practical comparison rather than an academic one. Look for a beer whose description mentions toast, crust or Vienna malt rather than caramel, and hold the glass up to the light before you taste it, since the style should read brilliant rather than hazy. Then buy one amber lager and one Märzen, pour them side by side at the same temperature, and notice which one you keep reaching for, because the difference between them is the difference between a beer built on toasted malt and a beer built on weight.