Thursday, May 11, 2023

India Pale Ale: What The Name Means And What India Actually Brews

Walk into almost any brewery in British Columbia and India pale ale will be on the list, which is worth pausing over, because the style is named after a country it did not come from. The India in the name records the market a beer was sold into rather than the town that invented it, and that distinction matters because the origin story printed on most sites is folklore: a London brewer adding extra hops so a cargo of ale would survive the voyage, which no period document supports. What the record does show is duller and better worth knowing, and so is the other half of the subject, which is that India itself drinks almost entirely lager and grows very few of the hops its own name style depends on.

Nine brown glass bottles standing in a row on a dark wooden counter, each with a different brightly coloured label, a cut lime and scattered spice seeds at the left end and a wooden bowl of green fruit at the right, against a dim shelf of jars

Keep the Name and Drop the Voyage Story

  • Understand that India in the name records the market a beer was sold into, not the town that invented it, and no document supports the Bow voyage legend.
  • Read freshness as the one durable tip, because hop aroma fades fastest in heat and light, so check the packaged-on date and keep the bottle cold.
  • Pair a hoppy beer with hot food carefully, because bitterness and heat amplify each other rather than cancelling out.
  • Treat Indian-grown hops as a shrinking crop, so an IPA brewed in India likely carries imported varieties rather than local ones.

The Bow Brewery Story Is Folklore

The tale runs that George Hodgson, brewing at the Bow Brewery in east London, supplied heavily hopped pale ale to the India trade around 1785 and so produced a beer that could cross an ocean without turning, which every IPA since descends from that accident. It is a tidy story with a named inventor, which is usually a warning sign in a history this thin. The historians who have gone through the records, Martyn Cornell most prominently and the brewer Mitch Steele in his book on the style, have found no evidence for it. Hodgson's beer was never called India pale ale but was advertised as a pale ale made for India, keeping ales strong enough to travel existed before he took the brewery over, and neither the Hodgsons nor the later owners of Bow claimed the invention.

What Bow did have was a commercial position worth having. The brewery sat close to the East India Company docks and the family extended unusually generous credit to the Company's factors, which explains why Bow's beer reached India ahead of the field better than a secret recipe does. The Burton brewers, whose water suits strongly hopped pale ale better than London's does, took over much of that trade later and at the Company's own prompting, once the Napoleonic blockade cut off their Baltic markets. The chemistry half of the legend is what keeps it alive, because it is half right: hop acids inhibit many of the bacteria that spoil beer, so a heavily hopped ale kept better than a lightly hopped one, and no brewer in 1820 understood why. The part nobody has documented is the motive, a single brewery raising its hop rate to solve a shipping problem.

The name arrived late and from nowhere expected. The earliest printed use of East India Pale Ale that anybody has traced is an advertisement in the Sydney Gazette in 1829, in Australia, and Bow Brewery did not use the phrase in its own advertising until 1833. The voyage then altered the beer rather than merely preserving it, since a cask rolled in a warm hold for months matures quickly, and it was that changed arrival, not the recipe, that made the style fashionable in London when the ships came back.

What India Actually Drinks

India is a lager country, and emphatically so. The big domestic brands are pale lagers, many brewed as high-gravity strong versions of themselves for buyers who want more alcohol for the money, and the small craft layer that appeared over the 2000s and 2010s sat on top of that. Distribution was the harder problem than brewing, because excise and licensing differ from state to state and in much of the country the economics favoured selling beer in the brewpub that made it rather than bottling it for three states away. Calling a pale ale brewed in Bangalore an India pale ale is therefore a small category error, and much of the confusion in print about the style comes from never noticing the difference.

Any piece about Indian craft beer written a few years ago points readers at Bira 91, founded in New Delhi in 2015 and for a while the most visible craft brand in the country. That recommendation has aged badly. Its parent company, B9 Beverages, was later reported to be carrying debt on the order of ten billion rupees, production was reported halted, and the founder Ankur Jain stepped down, which makes the name a warning rather than a suggestion. The lesson applies to every article on this subject, including this one, because a list of thriving breweries written in one year can be describing a company that no longer exists by the next.

Arbor Brewing Company is the sturdier example and the one that explains the Indian IPA better. It opened a brewpub in Bangalore in December 2012 as the Indian arm of a brewery founded in Ann Arbor, Michigan, and it made beer for the table it sat next to, local produce against an American hop bill. A brewpub brewing piney, citrus-forward pale ale in a hot city for people eating dosa the same evening is closer to what the phrase Indian IPA means than any export label is.

India Grows Hops, And Very Few Of Them

What the record actually shows is more interesting than any headline figure would have been. Hop growing in India is real, small and shrinking. It began in the 1970s in the high valleys of Lahaul and Spiti in Himachal Pradesh, in the western Himalaya, peaked in the mid-1990s at a few hundred hectares, and then fell away as cheaper American and Chinese hops undercut it; hop farming in Jammu and Kashmir stopped altogether. Indian-grown hops are generally lower in the alpha acids and aroma oils a modern IPA wants, so nearly every brewery in the country buys from Germany, Slovenia, the United States or China, and the loudest tropical characters in an Indian beer are imported ones.

A reader in British Columbia is looking at the same story from the other side of the Pacific, which is why it belongs on this site. Hops were grown commercially in the Fraser Valley through the middle of the twentieth century, and the last of that era's farms shut in the 1990s as the acreage moved south into Washington's Yakima Valley. The craft boom pulled growers back into the field, with new yards around Chilliwack and Agassiz and in the Southern Interior over the last fifteen years, planted largely with Cascade and Centennial, the two varieties that define the pine and grapefruit side of West Coast beer. Some of those farms have since cut acreage back as hop prices collapsed and breweries bought cheaper. Both countries learned the same lesson, which is that growing hops next to a much bigger, cheaper neighbour is hard work no matter how good the beer you want to make from them.

What Local Ingredients Actually Do In The Glass

The claim that figure once supported, that most Indian craft breweries experiment with local ingredients, is worth keeping in a smaller and truer form. Jaggery, the unrefined cane sugar used across Indian cooking, turns up in the kettle or the fermenter to lift alcohol without adding body. Tamarind brings a sour edge that reads a little like a wheat beer. Mango and jamun, the small purple berry sold on Delhi streets in summer, do the job that citrus and stone fruit hops do in an American version. Cardamom, black pepper, coriander seed and dried chilli appear in small amounts as seasoning rather than as a headline. None of it is measured anywhere, and these are seasonal one-offs from brewpubs rather than a category with statistics attached, which is itself the reason a percentage on the page was always a sign that somebody wanted the paragraph to sound authoritative.

Does An IPA Actually Work With Hot Food?

The advice usually given, that a bold IPA tames a spicy curry, is backwards. Hop bitterness and capsaicin heat amplify each other rather than cancelling out, and alcohol makes the burn worse, so a very bitter, very strong IPA poured against a hot dish raises the heat and adds a drying astringency on top. Carbonation and cold temperature scrub fat off the tongue, which is why a chilled pale ale works with something creamy like butter chicken or a tandoor dish with oil on the surface. Sweetness is the reliable extinguisher, so a hazy IPA with soft bitterness, or a malty amber, is the safer order when the food is genuinely hot.

That is not the same as saying hops and Indian cooking have nothing to say to each other. The citrus and tropical aromas in American hop varieties sit happily against coriander, mint, tamarind and mango, and a lower-alcohol, moderately hopped pale ale drunk very cold is a fine answer to a South Indian meal. Just do not ask the bitterness to put out the fire, because it pours petrol on it.

Freshness Is The One Tip Worth Keeping

The one piece of the older advice that survives is about freshness, and it applies with more force to a BC drinker than to anyone in Bangalore. Hop aroma is the first thing to fade in any beer, and heat, light and oxygen speed it up, so an IPA that tasted of mango in March can smell like almost nothing by August. Look for a packaged-on or brewed-on date rather than a best-before, buy from a store that keeps its stock cold instead of in a back room, and take it home to the fridge rather than the garage. Brown glass and cans beat clear glass, because light reacts with hop compounds and produces a skunky note within minutes of sun. A fresh pale ale on tap at a brewery you drove to beats almost any bottle on a shelf, for the dull reason that it never sat in a warm truck.

Frequently Asked Questions

Was IPA really invented for the voyage to India?

There is no evidence that it was, which is a more honest answer than the one most sites give. The name is real and the export trade is real, but no document from the period shows a brewer raising the hop rate to solve a shipping problem, and heavily hopped keeping ales were already being brewed in Britain for markets that had nothing to do with India. The story works best as a legend that attached itself to a style whose name invites one.

Can I find beer brewed in India on a BC shelf?

Sporadically, and not reliably enough to plan around. Indian brewing is overwhelmingly for its own domestic market, the exported volume is small, and what does arrive tends to come through restaurant channels rather than a liquor store. Distance is the bigger problem for a hoppy Indian beer specifically, since it has to travel warm, so if you do find one check the packaged-on date first and expect the loudest hop character from a beer brewed closer to home.

Keep The Name And Drop The Story

The useful part of this history is not the voyage and not the brewery, but the way a style name records a trade route and then keeps travelling long after the trade has gone. A brewer in the Fraser Valley making a piney pale ale is pouring a name that meant something entirely different in 1830, and a brewer in Bangalore making a West Coast IPA is doing the same thing from the other direction. One man solving one problem is easier to print than several breweries adapting a dry, heavily hopped beer to a long warm passage and a market that liked what the ship did to it, and it is the second, duller story that explains why the beer in front of you is bitter, bright and best finished young.